You are here:
website 1
News, Solutions for business

Successfully challenging discriminatory requirements in public procurement

In continuation of our publications on this topic, we share with you our experience of assisting a participant and our regular client in challenging the terms of the tender documentation in one of the procurements.

In this procurement, the procuring entity required the tenderers to use software and components from certain manufacturers to provide services, despite the fact that in this particular case, the use of equivalent software and components by the tenderers does not technically affect the possibility and quality of service provision.

According to part 4 of Article 23 of the Law of Ukraine “On Public Procurement” (the “Law”), technical specifications shall not contain references to a specific brand or manufacturer or to a specific process that characterises a product or service of a certain business entity, and if such a reference is necessary, it must be justified and contain the expression “or equivalent”.

Quite often, procuring entities formally comply with this requirement of the Law in their tender documentation and specify the expression “equivalent”. However, tenderers should keep in mind that formal compliance with the requirement of the Law to specify this expression in the documentation, but without providing tenderers with a real opportunity to offer such an “equivalent”, cannot be considered compliance with the requirements of Article 23 of the Law and the requirements of the Law in terms of the prohibition of discrimination against tenderers, and therefore such a requirement should be challenged.

In addition, the tender documents contained a requirement for tenderers to provide a certificate from the manufacturer to confirm the status (competence) of the tenderers to provide the services required by the procuring entity. At the same time, the procuring entity did not justify the need to establish the above requirement in the documentation, nor did it define the concept of “manufacturer” and specify what is meant by the status (competence) of the participants. This did not allow the participants to properly prepare their proposals, and therefore, such a requirement is discriminatory towards/in relation to the participants.

We advise bidders to carefully study the requirements of the tender documentation and, in case of detection of requirements that may be arbitrarily interpreted by the procuring entity, to immediately challenge them, as after submission of the bids, this opportunity will be lost, which may lead to rejection of the bid by the procuring entity or appeal of the procurement results by other bidders.

Smartsolutions’ attorney Sergii Krutii analysed the tender documentation, identified the above discriminatory requirements and prepared a complaint to the AMCU Board to exclude such requirements. The AMCU Panel sided with the participant and the complaint was upheld.

As a result, the rights of Smartsolutions’ client to participate in the procurement of services with an estimated value of over UAH 11 million and to have the opportunity to become the winner were protected.

We recommend that bidders who believe that the procurement conditions are discriminatory do not neglect your right to defend and challenge discriminatory requirements of the tender documentation.

If you need advice on legal issues or protection of your interests in court, the Smartsolutions team will provide you with professional assistance and assistance.

Share this post:
Rate this post:
0 / 5

Your page rank:

The contact person

Successfully challenging discriminatory requirements in public procurement
Oleksandr Paputsya
Attorney-at-law

Latest publications

A company manager reviews documents on critical enterprise status at his desk
12.11.2026
We explain how, after Resolution No. 1328, a company can prove its critical status and keep its employees reserved: the harm test, limits, deadlines and a checklist.
Smartsolutions and the Heraskevych Foundation: Case Study
06.11.2026
Since the beginning of 2026, Smartsolutions has been providing legal and accounting support to the Heraskevych Foundation. We describe the cooperation and Vladyslav Heraskevych’s feedback.
Bill No. 10225-d: Virtual Assets Market and Taxes in Ukraine
04.11.2026
The Smartsolutions team can help assess how the bill affects your company or your virtual assets: taxation, authorisation, accounting and preparation for the new requirements. Request a consultation and we will discuss your case.
Can a Ukrainian LLC Director Be Held Liable for Mistakes? What Business Owners Need to Know
When does an LLC director answer with personal assets for the company's losses, fines and debts? We examine four types of liability, insolvency risks and tools to protect the owner.
How to Register a Marriage in Ukraine in 2026
20.10.2026
A practical guide to marriage registration in Ukraine in 2026: required documents, applications through civil registration offices or Diia, shorter registration periods and considerations for couples living abroad.
Foreign Director of a Ukrainian LLC: Work Permit Rules
16.10.2026
An overview of the permit requirements for foreign directors of Ukrainian LLCs, remote management from abroad, company formation and direct management by a sole member.
Company Director: What Powers Do They Actually Have, and Where Are the Risks for Owners?
A practical overview of directors’ authority in Ukrainian limited liability companies, signature and approval arrangements, owner safeguards, and risks related to management decisions.
Enterprise Management and Single Tax in Ukraine: How to Distinguish Consulting from Prohibited Activities
06.10.2026
When KVED 70.22 is compatible with the simplified tax system, which powers may indicate actual enterprise management, and how to reduce tax risks in agreements and primary documents.
OSINT Partner Due Diligence in Ukraine: A European Defence Company Case Study
30.09.2026
A Smartsolutions case study on OSINT research and legal due diligence of prospective Ukrainian partners for a European defence company selecting a MilTech manufacturer for cooperation in Ukraine.
NBU Currency Liberalisation 2026: Changes for Business
An overview of the NBU’s foreign exchange regulation changes for legal entities, including the new limit for certain cross-border transfers, eligibility conditions, corporate expenses abroad and other permitted transactions.
Anna Savchenko, partner and manager of legal entity Smartsolutions
18.09.2026
An interview with Anna Savchenko, Partner and Head of Legal at Smartsolutions, about strategic thinking, the impact of artificial intelligence on the legal profession, trust within a team, reputation, and the principles of long-term client relationships.
Digital Piracy and Content Protection
28.08.2026
Vitaliy Voloshin, a lawyer at Smartsolutions, presented the experience of the ‘Clean Sky Initiative’ during a round-table discussion on the protection of creative content. Participants discussed measures to combat digital piracy, the blocking of illegal websites, criminal law protection mechanisms and the development of WIPO ALERT.