In our previous article, we examined the powers of a director of a Ukrainian limited liability company (LLC) and ways to oversee their decisions. We now continue the discussion from the perspective of directors’ liability. If a director enters into an unfavourable contract, breaches the law or causes losses to the company, practical questions arise: who is liable to creditors, and can damages be recovered from the director personally? We examine the types of liability that may apply to an LLC director, the circumstances in which their personal assets may be at risk, the consequences of breaches during insolvency proceedings and the tools available to protect the owner’s interests.
Owners often mistakenly assume that the director is responsible for everything
An LLC director’s liability depends on the nature of the breach and its consequences. In certain circumstances, the director may be held personally liable for losses caused to the company, breaches of labour law, administrative offences or criminal offences.
As a company officer, a director may be subject to four main types of liability: civil, disciplinary, administrative and criminal. Each has its own specific features, determined by the nature and seriousness of the conduct involved.
Civil liability of the director
Civil liability arises from breaches of civil-law obligations or damage to property. Its primary purpose is to compensate for losses or compel the performance of obligations. Grounds for liability may include failure to perform, or improper performance of, contracts (supply, lease or service agreements); causing financial loss to the company through unlawful management decisions; negligence when entering into an agreement that results in losses; and breaches of corporate law.
Disciplinary liability
Disciplinary liability concerns breaches of workplace discipline and official duties within an employment relationship.
Grounds for liability:
- repeated failure to comply with job instructions;
- failure to comply with instructions from the owner or general meeting within the employment relationship;
- breaches of internal workplace rules.
This type of liability is governed by employment law and relates solely to the employment contract. A director who is an employee may be subject to disciplinary measures under the general rules.
Administrative liability
Administrative liability arises from breaches of public-law requirements set out in the Code of Ukraine on Administrative Offences and other legislation.
Grounds for liability:
- breaches of occupational health and safety rules;
- failure to comply with fire-safety requirements;
- breaches of the rules governing certain types of business activity;
- failure to submit reports within the prescribed deadlines.
Sanctions for administrative offences may include fines, confiscation of property and other administrative penalties.
Criminal liability
Criminal liability is the most serious type and arises where offences under the Criminal Code of Ukraine have been committed.
Grounds for liability:
- forgery of official documents;
- misappropriation or embezzlement of company property;
- abuse of authority or official position;
- large-scale tax evasion;
- corruption offences.
Penalties for criminal offences may include fines, restriction of liberty, imprisonment and disqualification from holding certain positions.
Criminal liability requires proof of the director’s guilt. The process involves a pre-trial investigation and court proceedings. Possible interim measures include the seizure of assets and pre-trial detention.
For example, in an attempt to save the business during a crisis, a director decides to “hold back” employees’ official salaries for several months. This immediately raises the boundary between administrative and criminal liability. Unjustified non-payment of salaries for more than one month may bring Article 175 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine into play (a fine, corrective labour or even imprisonment for up to two years). In cases of large-scale tax evasion (Article 212 of the Criminal Code), the director will not be sent to prison, but a criminal record, the freezing of personal bank accounts and an obligation to repay millions in unpaid taxes to the state are guaranteed. Even for smaller breaches (such as late submission of tax returns or violations of cash-handling rules), the director regularly receives administrative offence reports and pays fines from their own funds.
When the director may actually have to pay out of their own pocket
For example, shortly before leaving office (or by arrangement with third parties), a director sells company equipment or real estate below market value, or knowingly enters into an unfavourable contract with a relative’s business. In such circumstances, the issue of recovering damages from the LLC director arises if the statutory grounds for liability can be established. Civil liability to the company applies here. Under the Ukrainian law on LLCs, a director must act in good faith, reasonably and in the company’s interests. If the director causes losses, the company’s owners (members) may bring a derivative claim (directly against the director as an individual). The court will order the director to reimburse the losses from their own funds. If there are insufficient funds in their bank accounts, the enforcement authorities will seize and sell their personal assets (a car or real estate).
When the risks remain with the company
Liability may be subsidiary (where the company is the primary debtor) or personal to the director, particularly in cases of intentional misconduct or gross negligence that cause losses to the company or third parties.
A director’s liability for an LLC’s debts depends on how the debt arose, the director’s conduct and specific statutory requirements. Separate rules apply in insolvency proceedings.
For example, a company accumulates debts to suppliers or banks, has no money in its accounts and lacks sufficient assets to meet its obligations. The director is aware of this but continues to act as though everything is fine. This is where the director’s subsidiary liability may arise in insolvency proceedings. Insolvency law clearly states that if a company shows signs of threatened insolvency, the director must apply to the court to open insolvency proceedings within one month. If the director fails to do so and conceals the company’s critical financial condition, and the company is eventually declared insolvent, creditors may ask the court to impose all outstanding LLC debts on the director personally. The legal entity’s debt becomes the individual’s personal, lifelong debt.
How business owners can structure their relationship with a director to protect the business
We discussed tools for controlling a director’s powers in detail in our previous article. These tools also help establish the limits of the director’s authority, document breaches and build an evidential record if it becomes necessary to hold the director liable.
To summarise, we recommend the following practical steps for directors:
- Legal compliance: keep up to date with the legislation governing your activities.
- Documenting decisions: maintain written records, particularly for important board or general meeting decisions.
- Liability insurance: where available, arrange D&O insurance (directors’ and officers’ liability insurance).
- Legal advice: consult a lawyer before entering into high-risk transactions.
- Responding to inspections: reply promptly to administrative warnings and enquiries to reduce the risk of escalation.
Accordingly, a company director should understand all four types of liability and minimise the risk of incurring them.
Business owners should establish effective mechanisms to protect against risks arising from a director’s activities. As a director may face civil, disciplinary, administrative and criminal liability, the owner should minimise the risk of dishonest or unsuitable conduct by the director.
To prevent abuses, actions beyond the director’s authority or the diversion of assets, the owner (or founders) should consider the following measures:
- Restrictions in the articles of association: establish financial limits. For example, the director may not enter into transactions worth more than UAH 500,000 (or dispose of property) without the written approval of the general meeting. The general meeting of members may restrict the executive body’s (director’s) authority to undertake certain transactions. It is advisable to include provisions in the articles of association requiring prior written approval from the general meeting for specified transactions. Examples include obtaining loans, credit or other borrowed funds, providing such funds to third parties, entering into or terminating contracts, or concluding settlement agreements above a specified threshold. It is also recommended that opening and closing bank accounts require prior approval from the general meeting. A contract entered into by a director in excess of the authority set out in the articles of association may be declared invalid.
- Contract with the director: enter into a detailed employment contract. Set out clear KPIs, reporting procedures and the amount of penalties or compensation for breaches of the contract.
- Corporate agreement: this instrument allows the decision-making procedures to be described in detail, certain actions by the director to be prohibited and safeguards against corporate disputes to be established.
- Delegation rather than concentration of powers: divide responsibilities between the director and the chief accountant. Avoid a situation in which one person both makes decisions and controls the finances.
- Regular audits: commission independent audits to monitor the company’s financial statements and assets.
- Change of authorised signatory: a director’s authority is confirmed by the Unified State Register of Legal Entities, Individual Entrepreneurs and Public Organisations. If concerns arise about the director’s conduct, promptly initiate their dismissal and register a new authorised signatory.
An LLC director has broad powers to manage the company and represent its interests. At the same time, the role carries significant responsibility and risks for both the director and the business owners.
Effective internal controls, a first- and second-signature mechanism, clearly defined restrictions in the articles of association and regular audits help reduce the risk of abuse and support secure company management.
In summary, attention to a director’s powers, liability and control mechanisms is an important part of protecting a business. Smartsolutions lawyers can help structure the relationship with a director, establish appropriate restrictions and prepare documents to protect the owner’s interests.
FAQ
Is an LLC director personally liable for the company’s debts?
Can a director be required to compensate the company for losses arising from an unfavourable contract?
Who can bring a claim for damages caused by an LLC director?
When can a director face criminal liability for unpaid salaries?
When may an LLC director be held personally liable during insolvency proceedings?
What documents can help prove a director’s misconduct and the resulting losses?
Your page rank:
The contact person












